Foolproof Guide for Grilling Fish

Contrary to the opinion of strict carnivores, the backyard grill is not just for steaks and ribs. Nothing fishy about it! When done properly, grilled fish is amazing and offers a ton of health benefits. But there are definitely some pitfalls to avoid, not to mention some tips to ensure a better and tastier fish grill experience.

Best Fish to Grill

You can honestly grill any fish, but the prep and grilling methods will vary. No doubt about it, though, some fish are simply more ideally suited for grilling — specifically heartier fish with denser flesh. Some of the best fish for grilling are salmon, tuna, redfish, snapper, monkfish, halibut, swordfish and mahi mahi.

Best Recipes for Grilled Fish

Different fish have different textures and flavor profiles, which affects both seasoning choices and grilling method. Here are some quick and easy recipes that regularly get a thumbs up in our household. For any recipes that call for placing the fish directly on the grill, be sure to oil the grates to keep the fish from sticking to the surface.

Salmon: Keep the skin on and grill skin-side down on indirect heat until some of the fat starts to release and the meat begins to flake (for medium doneness). The great thing about salmon is that it works well with either sweet or savory preparations. My favorite recipe for grilled salmon is to season it with salt, pepper and garlic powder and baste during cooking with a my personal recipe for Spicy Bourbon Basil Glaze (recipe below).

Tuna: Tuna is hearty enough to be placed directly on the grill. One delicious option is to marinade tuna steaks in soy sauce, sesame oil and ginger for about 20 minutes. Roll the marinated steaks in a mixture of white and black sesame seeds, then sear both sides on a hot grill for about 2-3 minutes per side (depending on thickness) for rare to medium-rare.

Snapper: Snapper is similar in consistency to redfish and can be grilled in the same manner — skin on, skin side down, indirect heat. A little milder and sweeter in flavor than redfish, I love to top it with mango salsa (diced mango, lime, red onion, fresh jalapeno, rice wine vinegar, cilantro).

Halibut, Swordfish or Mahi Mahi: Halibut has a sweet flavor similar to crab. Mahi is a little milder. Swordfish is a little heartier. All three can be cooked in steaks on medium heat with a variety of seasonings and should be cooked all the way through. Halibut is delicious with a simple seasoning of salt, onion powder, dill and lemon. Mahi works really well with southwest seasonings like cumin and garlic. Swordfish is yummy salted and glazed with a light brushing of orange marmalade thinned with olive oil. The mildness of all three lend well to experimentation.

Best Accessories for Grilling Fish

With the exception of heartier fish that can be cut into steaks and placed directly on an oiled grill grate, it’s better to use one of the following to keep fish from falling apart.

• Grill Basket: This works well for fish steaks if you’re not comfortable with placing directly on the grill. You can still flip it to get nice grill marks on both sides, but don’t have to worry about the fish meat sticking or breaking and falling through the grates. For best results, spray the basket with cooking spray prior to adding the fish.
• Grill Pan: Grill pans have holes or vented slats that allow the smoke to come through while providing a flat cooking surface. This works really well for filets (either with or without skin). If skin-on, the skin will still get crispy. Remember to use cooking spray!
• Cedar Planks: These are great to use with redfish or salmon and give the fish a really nice earthy flavor. Be sure to soak the planks in water for about 30 minutes prior to use (to prevent flare-ups) and discard them after use. Keep a spray bottle of water handy in case the wood catches fire while cooking. You can also have fun experimenting with various flavors by soaking the planks in apple juice or adding alcohol to the water (like whiskey or wine).
• Himalayan Salt Block: This works well for many different types of fish and provides a nice sear to seal in natural juices. Cooking on the block provides a mild saltiness, but you still need to season the fish. Preheat the salt block on a hot grill. To get a good sear, make sure the block is dry. After cooking, wait for the block to get to room temp then use a damp cloth or a brush to clean it so you can reuse it later. Do not submerge in water.

Best Way to Grill Small or Delicate Fish

Delicate, flaky fish (like trout) can dry out or break apart when grilled. When grilling this type of fish, create a moist and delicious all-in-one meal by wrapping filets in a foil pouch with some veggies, butter (or olive oil), white wine, lemon and your favorite seasonings. For a smokier flavor, you can grill smaller fish whole. The fatty skin will help preserve the moisture. In my experience, the best fish to grill whole is flounder. Simply score the top and continually baste it with seasoned butter combined with garlic and lemon.

6 Important Tips for Fish Grilling Success

1. Don’t marinade it in citrus for longer than 10 or 15 minutes, or you’ll end up with ceviche.
2. Cooking spray can be your best friend. Fish is delicate and can stick and break apart easily without it. Just don’t spray directly onto a lit grill grate or you’ll end up with a blow torch.
3. There is no one way to season any type of fish. However, a good rule of thumb is that oilier fish (like tuna or salmon) can handle sweet glazes, while milder fish are typically better with savory seasonings.
4. Like with grilled meats, it’s often a good idea to let the fish rest a few minutes after removing from the grill before cutting into it to keep it moist.
5. There are often small bones hiding in fish meat that can poke your gums or present a choking hazard, so pay attention when preparing and eating.
6. Remember to sanitize anything that comes in contact with the raw fish to avoid cross contamination.

. . .

RECIPE: Spicy Bourbon Basil Glaze